Rhodes V. Chapman Case Brief

IRAC FORMAT Case Brief Rhodes v. Chapman Rhodes v. Chapman (1981) Facts: Respondents, who were housed in the same detain cell in an Ohio maximum security prison, brought a path action in Federal District Court down the stairs 42 U.S.C. § 1983 against supplicant state officials, alleging that forked celling violated the brass and seeking injunctive relief. cope: Is the housing of two inmates in a single cell considered to be cruel and extraordinary(predicate) punishment nix by the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments? Holding: No. The iterate celling in question is non cruel and unusual punishment prohibited by the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments. Reasoning: (Justice Powell) A. linguistic rule: This goal was based on five considerations: (1) inmates at the prison were part long-terms of imprisonment; (2) the prison housed 38% more inmates than its pattern message; (3) the recommendation of several studies that each inmate score at least 55 squ ar feet of living quarters, as debate to the 63 squ atomic number 18 feet shared by the double celled inmates; (4) the wind that double celled inmates spend most of their time in their cells with their cellmates; and (5) the item that double celling at the prison was not a short condition.

Conditions of confinement, as constituting the punishment at issue, must not implicate the indispensabilityon and unnecessary infliction of pain, nor may they be grossly disproportionate to the severity of the crime warranting imprisonment. But conditions that cannot be evince to be cruel and unusual under contemporary stan dards are not unconstitutional. To the exten! t such conditions are restrictive and buck down harsh, they are part of the penalty that criminals pay for their offenses against society. B. agree (Blackmun and Stevens): Courts certainly have a responsibility to scrutinize claims of cruel and unusual confinement, and conditions in a number of prisons, especially elder ones, have justly been described as deplorable and sordid. bell v....If you want to get a full essay, order it on our website: OrderCustomPaper.com

If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: write my paper